The year

Every rated work is one ray, in the order it was photographed, round Bangkok's three seasons from the first batch in December 2025 to the latest. The longer the ray, the higher the rating; solid rays are V23, hollow-tipped ones V23 lite; the inner tracks are the five axes and gaps split the batches. Combined rating, the one on a work's page, and Measured half redraw the rays from V24, which only the works with a TIFF have. Ring by ring lays the same works out as tiles, one ring per quality, to follow one quality round the year.

The rising floor

Each quality V23 reads, as a channel through the year. Every work is a mark at its rung; the banks are the floor and the ceiling, where the lowest and highest tenth of the works sat at the time. A weir marks the day a quality stepped up for good, and the notes name what the Oracle found held. Read the lower bank: the weakest works improved more than the strongest.

Pace and surface

The pace of making, as a pulse: for every day of the year, how many works had been dated in the fortnight before it. The shaded storms are the bursts, the busiest quarter of the year. Below the line the batches answer: the Material and surface rung each was given, and how often the reads found a water stain.

Flaws

Every flaw V23's five reads named, drawn as it behaves on paper. The sheet shows where the reads placed them, every kind together; below, each kind with its own sheet and, along the year, the share of each batch's reads that named it. V23 lite names no flaws, so the early months are absent. Hover the sheet for a zone, or a batch for its share.

What goes with what

Every finding is a strand from a fact on the rim to the score it goes with, V24's scores and his votes among them. Facts a score is built from are left out of that score. Cyan goes with higher, ember with lower. The bright strands held up; the haze behind them are leads, still to be tested on new work. A fact read over several windows (3, 7 and 14 days) is one point on the rim. Hover or tap the rim to follow one fact or one score.

Five reads

V23 reads every work five times and takes the middle. Each work here is a column of five marks per quality, one per read, in the order the works were photographed: a column that sits as one block was a clear call, a split column a close one. Above, how few changed reads would have moved the rating a full point. Below, the rungs the measurement caps took away, and the run whose batch rated furthest above Peter.

Two engines

V23 reads the studio photographs; V23 lite reads the older phone photos. Thirty works were read by both. On the left, each of those works as a strand from its V23 rating to its V23 lite rating. On the right, the factors the Oracle tested against both ratings that went somewhere, each a needle: up for higher, down for lower, its two halves the two engines. Where the needle runs straight the engines agree.

Against the pattern

From everything measured about a work, the Oracle predicts each score V23 gave it. These are the works that broke the prediction furthest: the hollow mark is where the profile said the score would be, the solid one where V23 put it. A fall is a work that measures well and was read low; a leap, the reverse. Hover or tap a work to see it.

Each paper, its own year

One constellation per paper, grouped by how the paper is sized. Each ray is a painting on it, at its date on the year's clock (December at the top, running clockwise) and long for a high rating: solid rays V23, hollow tips V23 lite, the base dot his early triage. Inside, the five qualities V23 read on that paper against every paper (dashed), and a ring of the inks it took. Beside each, the spread of its ratings and what the Oracle found about the paper itself. Papers were used in different months, so read these as portraits, not verdicts. Hover or tap a ray to see the painting.

Beliefs under test

Each lane is one belief about the work, tested against the whole archive. The dot is what the data says now, the line its uncertainty, and the faint trail behind it where the same test stood in each of the Oracle's earlier runs. Right of the band the data agrees, left it disagrees; a "no effect" belief holds while its dot stays in the band.

The words

How often Peter's own writing reaches for each idea, per thousand words, from the first records of the practice to the Crucible year. Each phase is a layer laid down on the last, oldest at the bottom; each idea a vein whose width is how often it was written. The marked shifts held up: a rise or fall too large for chance across the sections written in those periods.

The sky over the table

The year drawn against the real sky. The rim carries the twelve signs; inside it runs the band of sky the Sun crosses, with its actual stars, constellations and Milky Way, which have slipped almost a sign from the signs named after them. Every painting sits where the Sun stood on the day it was photographed, its ray long for a high rating, so the year runs from its first sign round to its latest and the dark arc is the part still to come. Inside, the planets' paths across the same days, each drifting outward as the year goes on so that where a planet doubles back (retrograde) it draws a loop; the Moon's face on every photo day; and at the centre the Moon itself, from real imagery, as it stood that day. Hover or tap a painting to see the sky on its day; hover a planet for what the Oracle found about it.

The sky, and a borrowed sky

Every sky pattern the Oracle recorded, drawn as stars above the horizon, and below it, like a reflection, the same tests run on a borrowed sky: the real positions with their dates moved half the record away, so they belong to no painting. Each mark is one pattern, placed by its strength; the large stars passed as signals, and each is named. The dashed line on each side is the other side's outline, flipped across: if the planets had a hand in the work, the sky would outgrow its reflection. The figure states how much the two shapes share. Hover or tap a mark to find its twin.

The Oracle's own year

The Oracle runs again as the archive grows. Each ring is one run, the first at the centre; each finding a thread out from the run it was first tested, lit where it held as a signal, dim as a lead, dark where it fell to noise. The outer dark is what the Oracle could not test at all.

The hundred points

Twelve rungs

V24 measures each work with twelve tests, each scored from rung 0 to rung 5. Read this as a drilled core: one column per test, grouped by domain; one row per work, oldest at the top. The brighter the cell, the higher the rung. No votes and no model enter these scores. They measure physical facts and cannot see the quality of a mark.

The measured year

V24 measures 31 physical facts from every 16-bit TIFF. Each thread is one fact through the year, one point per batch, its middle value, on its own scale. Pick a thread to open it into every work. Hollow squares on the density threads are works whose blacks are crushed to the 4.0 ceiling, so read those with care.

Read and measured

Date first

Who picks the winner

Peter made thousands of forced choices between two works. For each measure, this asks how often the work it scored higher is the one he chose. A coin gets half. His votes helped shape V24's point system, so V24's scores are in-sample. No single work's votes are shown.

Two ways of looking

Paper by paper

Inside one batch, on one paper, which physical facts go with a higher V23 rating, and which with his votes? Each column is a paper with enough works to ask. A round mark is V23, a diamond is his votes. Cyan goes with higher, ember with lower. An ember strand joins two papers where the same fact seems to pull opposite ways, so it may mean different things on each.

Phone against TIFF

The weeks

The sheets

What a batch shares, and what can be predicted

Works photographed together are a batch. The needles show how much of each score's variation lies between batches rather than inside them, with the hollow mark the share left once the month is held. The grid below asks how well each kind of record predicts each score on works it has not seen. A larger circle is a better prediction. A grey dash means it did no better than guessing the average.

Every test

Every public finding from both Oracles, one mark each, in lanes by where its fact comes from.

The instruments, and what could not be tested

Flying white, and Oracle X's beliefs